PLANNERS gave permission for a new Hospice of the Valleys state-of-the-art day centre at The Works site in Ebbw Vale – despite objections from their own officers.

Members of Blaenau Gwent Council’s planning committee went against the recommendations of the council’s planning officers, who recommended rejecting the plans, describing them as “aesthetically displeasing”.

The hospice has already had outline planning permission for a site opposite Ysbyty Aneurin Bevan approved, but committee has now approved planning permission on “reserved matters”.

While there were no planning objections in regards to highways, accesses or environmental health, officers said the problem was the appearance of the building, which they claim does not fit in with the rest of the Works’ buildings.

In their report they said “the proportions and use of materials contradict the urban design theme for The Works” and “sustainable design principles in which to meet the BREEAM Excellent standard appear to have been overlooked”. Examples of this include omission of showers and lockers in association with cycle provision, and the potential for heat loss from the building because of its form.

Most damningly, in their report officers said: “The architectural form and design of the proposed hospice is that of a generic building that lacks innovation.

“Furthermore, it is considered that the juxtaposition of this traditionally designed building would not compliment the contemporary character of the hospital or surrounding area.”

But councillors ruled in favour of the plans, with many members of the committee saying they preferred the “friendly-looking” hospice plans to many of the existing buildings at The Works site, which they said looked like they were from the “space age”.

The plans feature six treatment rooms, a dedicated children’s suite, multi-purpose spaces and storage, a multi-function hall, office space, staff facilities, a library, training suite and staff accommodation.

Planning officers are to meet representatives from the hospice to discuss the conditions of the planning permission at a later date.

We can offer better care

ANDREW Richards, chief executive of Hospice of the Valleys told the committee: “The Hospice has been working in Blaenau Gwent for more than 21 years and has cared for nearly 5,000 patients, their families and loved ones.

“During this period we have had to provide essential care from a variety of make-do premises such as sports clubs, church halls and community centres.

“None of these premises are satisfactory and are certainly not conducive to good patient care.”

Mr Richards said the design was arrived at following extensive consultation with staff, board members, patients and members of the public.