A PSYCHIATRIC nurse who broke the arm of a violent patient while restraining him at a Newport hospital was fined £1,000 today.
Michael Murphy, 32, a married man with no previous convictions, of Station Avenue, Ynysddu, was described in Newport crown court today as "a caring, responsible nurse". He was also ordered to pay £400 costs. Murphy had admitted inflicting grievous bodily harm on the male patient at St Cadoc's Hospital, Caerleon, on August 9 last year.
Prosecutor Christopher Williams said that during a dispute, the victim elbowed Murphy in the face and he then threw the patient to the floor. And when Murphy pushed the patient's arm up his back, he fractured it. Judge David Morris said: "This was a difficult patient, mentally sick who had been criminally violent on many occasions in the past. "He became unreasonably violent striking the defendant for no good reason at all."
Passing sentence, the judge told Murphy: "While in employment as a specially trained mental health nurse, you inflicted a serious injury on a man entrusted to your care. You did so in rather special circumstances." The patient, the judge said, was behaving in a difficult, aggressive, violent manner.
"When reasonably remonstrated with by you and a colleague he became violent and struck you a blow with his elbow in the face."
It was accepted by the Crown that the patient required lawful restraint. "But you simply lost your temper and subjected him to force which was unnecessary and unlawful," the judge said.
The judge said he believed Murphy was full of genuine remorse for his loss of control that day.
Murphy, he added, had an outstanding career as a caring, responsible nurse.
It was likely he would never work as a mental health nurse again which would cause economic hardship to his family, the court was told.
Murphy's counsel Stephen Thomas says he was currently suspended and would inevitably lose his employment at St Cadoc's as well as his nursing registration which would have "profound effects on him and his family".
He said Mruphy had received a good education and planned to retrain. Murphy was ordered to pay the fine within 28 days.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article